Personal Injury Attorney in Colorado Springs

If someone else’s negligence has caused you harm, you deserve full and fair compensation.

Life turned upside down? We are here for you.

A serious accident can change everything in an instant. Suddenly, you’re dealing with pain, stress, and uncertainty about the future. Medical bills start piling up. You might be unable to work. The insurance company is already calling, and you don’t know what to say.

You’re left wondering: How will I afford these medical expenses? What if insurance denies my claim or offers too little? What are my legal options? Do I need an attorney, and who can I trust? If this sounds familiar, you’re not alone. Our Colorado Springs personal injury lawyers will help you move forward.

Not Sure What To Do? Read Our Injury Attorneys’ Advice.

We understand this is one of the most difficult times you’ve had to face, and you may be unsure of the best next step. Your actions in the days following your injury can impact your ability to recover the compensation you deserve. Here’s what you should do:

First, seek medical care right away. Even if you feel okay at first, injuries can take time to appear. You want to start documenting your condition immediately. Our Colorado Springs personal injury attorneys also advise you not to admit fault, and to gather evidence (photos, contact information, and a copy of the police report) if possible to help with your case. Contact us directly for more tailored advice — we offer free initial consultations for personal injury claims.

Seek personal injury legal services before speaking with insurance.

The goal of every insurance company is to pay out as little as possible. Our legal team will take every step needed from the beginning to get you full, fair compensation.

More than two decades of plaintiff’s personal injury experience

Hundreds of favorable settlements

100% tailored approach for your case

Why Choose Our Colorado Springs Personal Injury Attorney?

Choosing a lawyer is a big decision that can weigh heavily on the outcome of your case. You have one chance to secure the compensation you need. We’ll make it count.

Many lawyers have never argued before a jury or felt the pressure of standing up for a real person with everything on the line. We have. Maher & Maher’s personal injury attorney has spent decades trying cases and navigating high-stakes situations, making sure our clients are heard and believed. You need an aggressive trial lawyer with experience in the courtroom. We’re ready to fight for you.

Pre-Litigation Stage

This is the time between when you hire us and a lawsuit is considered. Many cases are settled during this timeframe.

Investigation

The first phase of your case is a time when we figure out whether you have a good case. We will be looking into the details of the injury event (crash, slip and fall, medical negligence, etc.). We will get the Traffic Crash Report, photographs of the property damage and your injuries, videos of the injury event, and insurance coverage for the person at fault. Remember, we are not typically suing the individual who was negligent in causing your injuries, we are looking at his or her insurance company to compensate you for your losses.

Treatment

While we are investigating your case, you are in the treatment phase of your case. We want you to get better. We want you to get evaluated thoroughly by qualified medical professionals so that your injuries are properly documented for the insurance company to consider. We will work with your medical providers to make sure that you are being seen and your injuries are taken seriously. Having an injury overlooked is detrimental to your health and your case. We will help you get the medical treatment you need.

Record

When your doctor releases you, we are going to get a complete and official copy of your medical records and bills. We usually get imaging (X-rays, MRIs, etc.) as well. It is important that the insurance company has everything it needs to properly evaluate your damages.

Demand Preparation

This is when we put the demand package together and send it to the insurance company. We will discuss your personal losses before we finalize the demand package so that we can convey how your injuries have impacted your life, your humanity, your family, and your joy. We put that all together and send it to the insurance company with a deadline to respond with a settlement offer.

Negotiation

The insurance company will not always accept your demand. If they offer something less than demanded, we negotiate with them, pointing out the strengths of your case and shining a light on the truth of how much you have been affected by the injuries caused through the negligence of their insured and how the law demands justice in your favor.

Settlement

If we reach an agreement with the insurance company, you agree to accept an amount of money in exchange for filing a lawsuit. You get money in your pocket, everyone gets paid and you are square with the world. Our goal is that you are “made whole” under the law and that you can now put this experience behind you and move on with your life.

Litigation Stage

This means we were not able to come to a settlement in the pre-litigation stage, and you have chosen to file a lawsuit. This is your choice. Just because you file a lawsuit does not mean you will go to trial. In fact, most cases are settled before going to trial.

File Complaint

The Complaint is the first document filed to start a lawsuit. It sets forth the facts and legal theories under which you are entitled to justice, a remedy at law. If the claim was being considered by an unreasonable insurance adjuster in the Pre-Litigation phase, the Complaint usually gets the case assigned to a new adjuster and a lawyer. You get a fresh evaluation of your case. Sometimes, that is enough to get a reasonable settlement offer.

Case Management Plan

After we file the Complaint and we have it served on the Defendant, an attorney is provided to them by their insurance company. We then work with this attorney to develop a plan for deadlines for the steps in preparing for trial.

Discovery

This is where we request documents and information from the other side and subpoena records from third parties. We conduct depositions, hire experts to review your case, file motions, and work to build a solid case for trial.

Mediation

The court will order that you and the defendant attend mediation to try to settle the case before trial. During mediation, a negotiator will help both sides come together, pointing out the strengths and weaknesses of the case. Most cases are settled at mediation.

Trial

If no settlement is reached in mediation, the lawsuit will proceed to trial. A jury will hear your case and determine how much money you receive. At Maher and Maher, we are trial attorneys, and we have a lot of experience in trial. This is where you don’t want a “settlement” attorney, but you need a trial lawyer. Trials are a battle, and you will need lawyers who have combat experience to take your case to a successful verdict.

Post-Trial

After the jury hands down your verdict, we petition the court to add interest and costs of litigation to the verdict amount. Once the court decides the final judgment, we submit that judgment to the insurance company for payment, and your case is over (unless there is an appeal). Our goal is that you are “made whole” at this point, having all your injuries, harms, and losses recognized and compensated under the law.

Client Testimonial: Personal Injury Attorney Colorado Springs

“I originally started with a different law firm and wasn’t getting results. When I transitioned over to Maher & Maher, there was a total shift. They exceeded expectations.”

Our Personal Injury Attorney Results

Your case is not just a case to us. You’re family — and we’d fight for you like we’d fight for our own. See what we’ve secured for clients like you who suffered a personal injury in Colorado.

Pueblo Jury Awards $1.36 Million to Local Woman Injured by Drunk Driver

Our personal injury attorneys secured a $1.36 million verdict for our client, a school teacher, after a devastating crash left her with life-altering injuries, including a traumatic brain injury.

Nearly $300,000 Settlement

Our clients were rear-ended by an 18-wheeler and initially offered just $18,000 by the insurance company. Our Colorado Springs injury law firm successfully negotiated a nearly $300,000 settlement without filing a lawsuit.

Maximum Settlement Secured for Grieving Mother

After a car accident left our client injured and tragically took the life of her infant son, the insurance company and police unfairly placed blame on her. We brought in an expert accident reconstructionist to uncover the truth. In the end, we secured the maximum possible settlement for our client.

Expert Personal Injury Lawyer, Colorado Springs Spotlight

If you’re looking for the best personal injury lawyer in Colorado Springs, choose an attorney with an unbeatable record. Attorney Keith Vance has over 27 years and well over a thousand cases under his belt. Keith represents people injured by automobile collisions, semi-truck accidents, motorcycle wrecks, nursing home neglect, defective products, and medical malpractice. He also practices in the areas of civil rights litigation, criminal defense, and civil and criminal appeals. His track record includes millions of dollars in settlements for his clients, a testament to his skill.

Keith earned his law degree in 1997 from the University of Nebraska College of Law. He began his career defending negligent drivers on behalf of insurance companies, then shifted his focus in 2000 to fighting for the rights of the injured. Keith’s professional affiliations include the Colorado Trial Lawyers Association, the American Association for Justice, and the Colorado Bar Association. He is board certified in Civil Trial Law (since 2013) and a graduate of Gerry Spence’s Trial Lawyers College. Keith is also an AV Preeminent–rated attorney by Martindale-Hubbell’s peer review rating process, and is recognized as a Colorado Super Lawyer.

Joe Maher, Maher & Maher Law, voted best DUI attorney Colorado Springs by peers
Keith’s favorite quote:

“If you can learn a simple trick, Scout, you’ll get along a lot better with all kinds of folks. You never really understand a person until you consider things from his point of view, until you climb inside of his skin and walk around in it.”

— Harper Lee, To Kill a Mockingbird

Hundreds of Five-Star Reviews

Kinds of Personal Injury Cases We Take

Car Accident

If you were injured in a car accident that wasn’t your fault, we’ll work hard to get you proper compensation for your recovery.

Truck Accident

Being hit by an 18-wheeler can cause serious injuries, if not death. You may feel lucky to be alive. We’ll help you fight for what you deserve.

Motorcycle Accident

Motorcycles have a right to be on the road. If you’ve been injured by a careless driver, we can help you recover full compensation.

Slip and Fall

If you’ve been injured on someone else’s property, we’ll see to it that you get what you need to recover from your injuries.

Wrongful Death

Losing a loved one due to an accident or someone else’s negligence is devastating. We are here to support you and fight for you and your family.

Brain Injury

Mild or severe, you deserve fair compensation so you can focus on recovery. Our injury attorneys will fight for what you need.

Insurance Bad Faith

Insurance companies must follow the law, too. We can assess if you may have a claim for bad faith against an insurance company.

Understanding Personal Injury Lawsuits in Colorado

Each personal injury case is unique and may take several months or even years to resolve. Typically, a case will go through pre-litigation and then litigation if it can’t be resolved by settlement. No matter where your case goes, our skilled Colorado injury attorneys will guide you through every stage of the process and fight aggressively for full justice.
We handle the insurance companies and complex claims process, so you can focus on getting better. Let’s talk about your case.

FAQs About Colorado Springs Personal Injury Legal Services

Who pays after a personal injury lawsuit?

Most personal injury case resolutions are funded by an insurance company, not an individual. Yes, a person’s negligence caused your injuries, but we’re not here to bankrupt them — we’re here to hold their insurance company accountable. That’s why they have coverage in the first place.

The goal of a personal injury claim in Colorado is to help you recover what you’ve lost — physically, financially, and emotionally. That includes compensation for medical bills, lost wages, pain and suffering, and the loss of enjoyment, comfort, security, and overall well-being. Insurance companies often try to avoid paying what’s fair, and it’s our job to make sure they do.

What happens during the pre-litigation stage?

This is the time between when you hire us and when we decide if a lawsuit is necessary. Many cases settle during this stage.

Here’s what to expect:
Investigation: We gather all the facts to see if you have a strong case — police reports, photos, videos, and insurance details. Remember, we’re not suing the person who caused your injury; we’re seeking compensation from their insurance company.
Treatment: Your health comes first. While you focus on recovery, we ensure your injuries are properly documented so the insurance company takes them seriously. If you need help finding the right care, we’re here for that too.
Record: Once your doctor releases you, we collect all medical records, bills, and imaging (X-rays, MRIs, etc.) to show the full impact of your injuries.
Demand preparation: We build a compelling case that explains how your injuries have affected your life, your humanity, your family, and your joy. Then, we send your demand package to the insurance company with a deadline to respond with a settlement offer.
Negotiation: If the insurance company offers less than what’s fair, we push back. We highlight the facts, your suffering, and the law that supports your right to proper compensation.
Settlement: If we reach an agreement, you receive a payout without going to court. The goal is to make you whole again so you can put this behind you and move forward.

What happens during the litigation stage?

If we couldn’t reach a fair settlement in pre-litigation, you have the choice to file a lawsuit. Filing doesn’t mean you’ll go to trial — most cases still settle before that point.

Here’s what to expect:
Filing the complaint: This officially starts the lawsuit. It lays out the facts and legal reasons why you deserve compensation. Often, this moves your case to a new insurance adjuster and attorney, which can lead to a fresh look and a better settlement offer.
Case management plan: Once the defendant (the person you’re suing) is served, their insurance company assigns them a lawyer. We work with this attorney to set deadlines for trial.
Discovery: This is where we build a rock-solid case. We request information from the other side, subpoena records, conduct depositions, hire experts to review your case, and file motions to prepare for trial.
Mediation: Before trial, the court requires both sides to attempt mediation. A neutral third party helps negotiate a fair resolution. Most cases settle here.
Trial: If mediation doesn’t work, we take your injury case to Colorado court. A jury hears the evidence and decides how much you should be compensated. This is where you’ll want experienced trial attorneys — like us — who know how to fight and win in the courtroom.
Post-trial: If you win, we ask the court to add interest and legal costs to the verdict. Once finalized, we collect the judgment from the insurance company, and your case is officially closed (unless there’s an appeal). Our goal is that you are “made whole,” having all your injuries, harms, and losses recognized and compensated under the law.

How long do I have to file a claim?

In Colorado, you typically have two years to file a personal injury claim. However, car accident claims have a three-year deadline. Missing these deadlines could mean losing your right to compensation, so don’t wait.

What if the insurance company offers me a settlement?

Don’t accept an insurance company’s first offer before talking to a lawyer. Their goal is to pay as little as possible, so early offers are often far below what you deserve. We’ll review your offer and let you know if it’s fair, or if you should fight for more.

What if I was partially at fault for the accident?

Colorado follows a modified comparative negligence rule. That means you can still recover damages if you were less than 50% at fault, but your compensation will be reduced based on your share of the blame. We work to minimize your fault percentage and maximize your payout.

What if I need a pedestrian injury attorney?

If you’ve been struck by an automobile as a pedestrian in Colorado, we are on your side — and so is the law. Call us at 719-301-7500 to speak directly with a local pedestrian injury attorney who will guide you through your options and fight for the compensation you deserve.

How much does it cost to hire a personal injury attorney?

We understand money is a concern — especially when you’re dealing with medical bills and lost income. Your consultation is free, and we’ll be honest with you about whether hiring a lawyer is worth it for your case. If you choose to work with us, our personal injury attorneys work on a contingency fee (you owe nothing until we collect) and will petition the defendant’s insurance company to pay out legal costs if the case goes to trial.

Resources From Our Colorado Springs Personal Injury Lawyers

Handcuffed individual representing a first DUI arrest in Colorado Springs.

What to Do Immediately After a Personal Injury Accident →

Read the steps to take immediately after a personal injury accident in this comprehensive article.

View Article…

Handcuffed individual representing a first DUI arrest in Colorado Springs.

Compensation: How a Personal Injury Lawyer Can Help After a Car Accident →

Facing your first DUI arrest in Colorado Springs can be overwhelming, but this comprehensive guide will walk you through the process, from understanding the laws and potential consequences to navigating the legal system.

View Article…

Handcuffed individual representing a first DUI arrest in Colorado Springs.

Brain Injury Personal Injury Claims: What You Should Know →

Gain critical insights into brain injury claims, including legal steps, compensation factors, and expert tips to guide your case effectively.

View Article…

Our Personal Injury Law Firm

Maher & Maher’s Personal Injury law firm has offices on the north side and downtown Colorado Springs. Our attorneys are passionate about serving in the communities they live and raise their families in.

Our local DUI lawyers serve clients in:

colorado counties - Maher and Maher Law, Colorado Springs

Get the Compensation You Deserve

We’re ready to listen, answer your questions, and start fighting for the compensation you need to fully recover.

Call 719-301-7500 or fill out our form to speak with one of our qualified personal injury attorneys for free.

Schedule Your Free Consultation

Call 719.301.7500 or fill out our form to talk about your case with our personal injury attorney for free.